Sugar Mill Hotel

The entire staff is very friendly and accommodating. The breakfast was consistently good and quick. The dinners were the best, delicious every time! Our room was wonderful. The beach and pool very nice. Highly recommend you go there!

This was our first visit to the Sugar Mill Hotel but certainly won’t be our last. What can I say about a place that welcomes you like a good friends and treats you to the best service and food on the island. Check-in was seamless, with Andrea welcoming us and explaining all the resort had to offer. Shantel, our server at Tramonti restaurant was warm and professional and Carlos the bartender at the beach bar was a true mixologist and served the best Painkillers ever! The Sugar Mill restaurant was also a pleasure, with excellent quality food and great wine selection. Our stay was too short but left us wanting to return for many years to come.

We have been coming to the Sugar Mill for many years and decided to book 3 nights of our 12 night stay on the new 50’ Catamaran. Captain Fiona and first mate BJ made our stay delightful. The food is excellent and we saw many places we have not seen on the many day trips we have taken on various charters. It was a bit windy on our trip but the Captain always found us a calm buoy in a protected cove each night. We had some great snorkeling at the Indians and other places… We will definitely do this again on future trips!

We did a lot of research, looking for a property that was not large, on a beach, with beautiful sunsets, quaint bar, a superb restaurant and Sugar Mill Hotel came up time and again. Based on the review, we decided to book for two weeks, and we’re not disappointed. We even got engaged.! Rupert and Andrea are superb hosts and looked after all our needs. The staff is amazing. The rooms are amazing. The restaurants are amazing and we had the most relaxing time. Will we go back again? I think it’s a safe bet.

Love staying here - not your usual resort - rooms are all different set on hilly property pool was perfect with honor bar food - ohhhh amazing and service outstanding restaurant can get crowed on particular evenings please see Georgie the adorable kitty that hangs by the restaurant andrea and rubert will help you with any requests or questions you may have.