The Caledonian Edinburgh, Curio Collection by Hilton

Hotel did not meet our expectations. Room was not clean. Walls were dirty. Air vents were filled with dust. Linens and towels old and worn. Rug was worn and tattered. Did not receive any amenities until third night in to a five night stay. Asked for wake up call that was not received, which had us running late for the day’s appointments. The reason I selected three and not one star is due to its great location and staff’s friendly attitude. Breakfast was ok. Coffee served warm at best. Will look for any another option when next in Scotland.

Had a lovely experience on my birthday came for bday drinks with the girls!! Excellent service from Rebecca, Lukasz, Evie, Tahlia, Isla, Magnus, Ellis and George. Quick service and excellent recommendations

Had the best experience here while celebrating a friends birthday. The service was excellent delivered by Rebecca, evie, Tahlia, Magnus, Ellis, George and Lukasz

We chose The Caledonian for a special occasion and spent a significant number of points expecting something memorable. Unfortunately our room looked directly onto active construction, with workers able to see inside, so we had to keep the curtains closed for privacy and were woken by the noise. We flagged it the moment we arrived and asked to move, but were told that wasn't possible. The efforts to put things right afterwards were disorganised, including a complimentary breakfast that had been promised but never recorded. A lovely hotel, badly let down by the room we were given and the way the situation was handled.

Thank you to Nitin and his team at the Caledonian. I had a wonderful evening there catching up with university friends. The atmosphere was relaxed yet with a real sense of occasion. The attention to detail throughout the evening really stood out, from the food to the service. A special mention to Lukasz and Lucy, who looked after us brilliantly and made us feel so welcome. We then enjoyed some truly special cocktails at the Caley Bar, where Asha and Ellie were fantastic. My cocktail recommendations are the coconut Massaman with its spherical ice cube and the Ceviche for a savoury treat. A really memorable evening with great company, food, drinks and service. We’ll definitely be back!