Garden City Hotel

My husband and I traveled to Long Island for a wedding. We booked a room with a king size bed & it was lovely. It had a couch & coffee table, desk & chair, large dresser with a door to the mini-fridge. The bathroom had a large walk-in shower. In the closet, they provided bathrobes & slippers, a safe, iron/ironing board & hairdryer. There was also complimentary bottles of water, tea & coffee fixings with a small keurig. There really was nothing we needed. One really made our stay special was the how welcoming the staff was from the moment we entered. Our bellhop, Lukas, was especially impressive. He was professional & made sure we knew all the amenities that were available but he was also very friendly & offered to help us in any way he could. He not only brought our luggage to the room, but he took the luggage racks from the closet & set everything up. He made sure we knew all the features in our room as well. The next night, as we returned from a wedding, he greeted us & asked if we had a good time. He took the extra time to make us feel like we were not merely guests but people who mattered. We would absolutely stay there again.

I have been to the Red Salt Room at the Garden City Hotel in the past, the food was always amazing and the room was gorgeous. I decided to host a company dinner in the Red Salt Room because of my memories at this location. I must say, of all the events I've ever had to book, this was the smoothest and most exciting one to do and it is all thanks to Chris Buffa. He is very smart, kind, helpful and fun! He listened to everything I wanted and needed and he worked with me to make it work. The cocktail hour and dinner was a huge hit! Everyone had an amazing time, there was not one single complaint from anyone. I lost count of the number of times people thanked me for holding this event in the Red Salt Room. The room was even more gorgeous than I remember and everyone was stunned at the beauty of it! The staff was so kind, caring and happy to help us, they made everything so special for us! They really treated us so well. The food was plated like a work of art and so delicious! The drinks were just as amazing. Everyone wants to come back to the Garden City Hotel for events and so do I. I look forward to future events and working with Chris. (I work for Northwell Health and it was a dinner of 70 people to welcome the new residents that joined us.)

Excellent hotel. The atmosphere at the hotel is always first class. The staff treats you like you are at a 5 star hotel. Extremely helpful and friendly. The service is impeccable. The facility is spotless and the rooms are very well appointed and very clean. Would highly recommend and would definitely stay there again. Best hotel on Long Island!

The hotel amenities and hospitality are above reproach. I had one of the best steaks at the restaurant, not to mention it has a very romantic vibe.

The absolute worst hotel stay ever. There was a party going on the first floor. Music was blaring until 1am. Will never stay there again.