Il Castelfalfi

I booked a 4 night stay for my wife and I not knowing what to expect as I’d never heard of the hotel nor been recommended it by anyone. It was a last minute trip booked a week before our visit. The minute we entered the hotel into the lobby I knew it was going to be a pleasurable experience. The decor, quality of the materials were fantastic and the service from the get go was exceptional. We got escorted to our room on the second floor which was overlooking the Tuscan hills. We had a large terrace with stunning views. The room itself was lovely, everything I’d expect from a 5 star hotel charging £1,300 a night. Bathroom was perfect too. We ate at 2 out of the 3 restaurants. Both very good indeed. Local produce and in season. All I would say is that any more than 4/5 days and you may find yourself wanting to venture out of the estate for food as the menu may get a little familiar, however it’s all delicious. The spa itself is exceptional however I had booked 4 massages for my wife and I. My first was average, her first was good, my second was good but my wife’s second wasn’t good at all. For the money I would have expected the treatments to have been exceptional. Perhaps we just got unlucky with the therapists. We would definitely return though. The staff are exceptional and the estate itself is stunning.

Dear Castelfalfi Team, I would like to thank you for the truly wonderful experience we had during our stay at your hotel. Everything was beyond our expectations , from the exceptional concierge service to the relaxing spa, and from the delicious cocktails to the warm and attentive hospitality. The hotel is of the highest standard, the rooms are exquisite, and the service was amazing . We will definitely return in the future and will gladly recommend your hotel to our family, friends, and clientele.

An absolutely exquisite dining experience from start to finish. The ambiance was refined yet inviting, with soft lighting, tasteful décor, and a sense of quiet luxury. Every dish was a masterpiece!!! Beautifully presented, perfectly balanced in flavor, and made with the freshest ingredients. The service was impeccable: attentive without being intrusive, with staff anticipating our needs before we even asked. From the first sip of wine to the last bite of dessert, every moment felt special. This is not just a restaurant, it’s a place where fine dining becomes an art form. I will absolutely be returning !!!! x

Lunch at Castelfalfi was pure perfection. From the moment we arrived, the service was flawless — warm, attentive, and genuinely caring. And the food… wow. The ravioli was nothing short of heavenly: delicate pasta, rich filling, and a sauce so good it should be famous. Every detail made us feel like royalty. Easily the best dining experience we’ve had in Toscana!

My husband amd I had the pleasure of staying at castelalfi with our newborn baby this summer. I want to preface that for me to write this review alone is a big deal because hardly ever do we feel that the experience was SO INCREDIBLE, or at that SO TERRIBLE to write a review. I’m happy to share our experience was INCREDIBLE. As seasoned travelers we have very high expectations of hotels. This was our 4th trip to Italy, 3rd to the Tuscany region and 1st with a baby. We were looking for an upscale, 5 star property, family friendly, modern Italian property. We were a little nervous when we booked Castelalfi because it seemed like it checked all those boxes and it was too good to be true. We didn’t want it to feel stuffy or unauthentic. We also, didn’t want it to feel too much like a kid resort. The staff here was so incredible in helping us book the perfect family friendly wine tastings, and helping us navigate a few travel mishaps like a flat tire on our rental car. We are forever thankful to this amazing property and staff! We can’t wait to return with our family and friends!