Four Seasons Hotel New York

The Four Seasons in NYC certainly lives up to its reputation in some ways, but the experience didn’t fully justify the price. The location is fantastic and the property itself is undeniably beautiful, with elegant design and well-maintained spaces that feel luxurious. The rooms are spacious and comfortable, though slightly less impressive than expected for a hotel at this level. While everything was clean and well-appointed, it didn’t quite have the “wow” factor you’d hope for. Service was professional, but at times felt a bit impersonal and inconsistent. There were moments of great attentiveness, but also times when requests took longer than expected or lacked follow-through. Overall, it’s a good stay in a prime location, but given the high cost, there are other options in NYC that may offer better value and a more memorable experience.

We had a fantastic time at the Four Seasons NYC. From the moment we checked in until we left. Our flight was very late, 5+ hours late due to an American Airlines equipment problem. The staff was very efficient in getting us to our room and our room service dinner was great. No request was left unanswered, services were amazing from housekeeping, bellmen, doorman and everyone we encountered. Our room was beautiful on the 44 floor with fabulous views of the city. The bed was very comfortable and the decor modern with good lighting and all the outlets etc. we needed for our electronics. My husband loves the app where he can request ice, or anything we need and it is quickly attended to. We also loved the fresh cookies, candy and fruit that were waiting for us when we arrived from dinner most nights. Breakfast in the Garden Restaurant was also wonderful. Our server had been there since the hotel opened and was gracious and efficient. The entire staff at the Four Seasons made our 7 night stay perfect.

Returned to the Four Seasons New York for the first time since it re-opened (second visit, overall). We had a terrific stay -- chose a Junior Suite -- got a room on the 27th floor. Everything was in order. Carpet looked new. Bed extremely comfortable, and the HVAC worked perfectly. Room nicely equipped with comfortable furniture. Quiet, especially given that we overlooked 57th street. The lighting in the hotel was spot on -- and that's a sore point for me in many hotels these days (see my last review of terrible state of The Carlyle). Housekeeping didn't miss a beat. I was impressed with just how friendly each and every staff member was during our stay -- I had to pinch myself to remind me that I was in New York City. We didn't use the restaurant. I'd gladly come back -- and given that I've forsaken The Carlyle due to their regrettable recent renovation, will very likely do so. Nicely done.

Not much I can say besides: Four Season Perfection! Not a single thing to complain about. Staff is absolutely fantastic, knows everybody’s name, very friendly. Front desk and concierge desk are the type of people I would hire had I a 5-star hotel. Breakfast staff is also very nice and accommodating (many names I to list, but mentioning Milton here who’s a character every hotel would want to have). Rooms are great, super quiet, super clean. And always on time cleaning and turn-down service. Absolutely recommend.

The Stay at the Four Seasons near Central Park was nothing short of amazing! Thanks to Christina G. for all of the help! Every touch the staff could have made- they made it! From a subtle yet elegant birthday surprise for my 13 year old daughter to a ride in their towncar around town the staff, accommodations and venue were spectacular! amazing Views from the guest rooms.