The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel

We absolutely loved the Carlyle! It was our first time, as we usually stay across the street. We far preferred the Carlyle, its wonderful service, beautiful restaurants, and old world charm. We have found our new city getaway place abs can’t wait to return!!

The Carlyle is a New York classic, great location and an ideal spot for a first timer in the Big Apple. Room was super comfortable , the food in Dowlings restaurant was delicious, Benelmans bar was busy, thank you Dimititrous for always getting us a spot to sit. The Conceirges did a fabulous job booking our trips and restaurants, highly recommend Pastis and Balthazar for dinner. Always getting us express tickets for things like Top of the Rock, Empire State Building & Circle line. Walk the high line and see Grand Central Station.

I would have liked to leave a rave review, because of the hotel’s history (guests have included Jackie O and Princess Diana) and the exceptional hospitality and service. But to pay $1,000 for a small room (no matter how chic the decor) with a tiny bathroom with kid-size sink and no tub is crazy. We were even upgraded to a “deluxe king,” so wonder what the less luxe rooms are like. One of the reasons we booked for my mate’s birthday was to enjoy the ambience of the Carlyle’s famed Bemelman’s piano bar. It has become such a tourist trap that we couldn’t get a seat or table for two nights running, though priority was promised to hotel guests. Staff was apologetic and tried to accommodate us in a gallery” by the line of wannabe entrants and guests streaming by to use the restrooms. No thanks. Also, the staff is by far more elegant than most guests — expect yoga pants, crop tops, baseball caps and sneakers in public areas.

I booked a night for my wife and I to celebrate her 50th birthday. I made a one sentence mention in the booking (via their website) The hotel upgraded us to a suite, had ballon (several round ballon’s, plus a 5 and a 0), cake, desserts, and a card waiting for my wife! They went way above and really made it special. Also, as a guest you can more easily get into Bemelmans piano bar, a very NYC experience. Will definitely go back, next time will book the dinner show in the restaurant. Thank you, Carlyle. (Btw also got upgraded at the rosewood in Bermuda. !)

I’m lost for words … if you want to step back in time to a Hollywood movie and experience unparalleled service, the Carlyle is for you. I spent 4 nights here when I eloped to New York to get married and it was impeccable start to finish. Any hotel that has a manned elevator is for me ! The bar is just elegant, stylish and a must visit. However just be mindful it’s small and has a great reputation with New Yorkers so it’s not always easy to get a table. This hotel is oozing personality and class and if you stand still long enough you are certain to see a celebrity or two ! We stayed in a suite and every whim was catered for . If you have a special occasion coming up this must be on your list. Ps start saving now 🙈