Poets Cove Resort & Spa

We went to Poet's Cove marina early this summer. At one point we heard that the dock was booked out so were disappointed. When we arrived, we thought we'd take our chances and speak with the dock office person and the other dock staff. We found them so helpful in helping accommodate us as they updated their bookings (i.e. some boaters don't show up). We were impressed with how they went out of their way to help us - the communication was key, efficient and very professional. Because of this, we booked Labour Day weekend, which just happened to be our special anniversary. We so appreciated the very personal, warm welcome from all the dock staff. They are so hard-working and so approachable. Communication has been top-notch - especially from the office manager - thank you CL!! This is a very popular marina and we can see why. Please know that you truly made our anniversary special. We will be back!!

The room was decent except for the plastic wrapped cups (baffling that an island hotel is not environmentally sustainable). Staff were nice and as so many places are short handed, did a good job although the gym was quite dirty. Big complaint is the hotel never let me or other guests know about the band that played until 1030 right outside our balcony. Couldn’t sit outside to enjoy the peaceful surroundings that we had paid handsomely for. Very disruptive & disappointing to plan a visit to a peaceful place & it be ruined by the noise.

All the other terrible reviews are correct! Although there are fantastic views from the balcony facing the marina, there were numerous issues. Threadbare stuffed armchairs, ice bucket provided but no ice machine in the hotel, old furniture, no charging ports for your electronics, front desk staff could care less and look annoyed if you approach them let alone ask for something, no lotion, no AC, the Moorings Cafe has terrible service (very slow barista) as well as 2 large soy lattes that were half foam, and lower pool/hot tub out of service due to “maintenance issues”. Front desk told us when we asked upon check in that they had no idea when it would be fixed and had already been closed for 2 days, plus the 3 days we were here. Upper pool/hot tub area filled with noisy kids. We heard from people who have been coming here for years that it has really gone downhill since it changed ownership some years ago. Too bad, location is beautiful and peaceful, but this is not a great hotel by any stretch of the imagination!

Good service and good food. A pleasant surprise on the island. Went with my kids and sister. Something for everyone. Too bad there was no pizza on the menu that night

Beautiful resort, amazing scenery, wonderful staff and fine dining -- stay marred, however, by closed waterfront pool; no robes, lotion or bottled water in rooms; minimal spa amenities; and great difficulty trying to book kayaking (no one on location with slow to return calls). Changes to the above would otherwise make this a 5 star stay.