Hotel Casa Lucia

Stayed here for 2 nights on our trip to Argentina. The only positive about this hotel is the location. Hotel located in quiet, posh neighborhood of Buenos Aires. It’s in the middle of everything. When we decided to book 2 nights here, we decided to splurge a little bit. We thought it would be nice summarization of our great 16 days vacation. Instead, we were disappointed. The hotel “renovation “ I can’t even comment on because it looked to me like our room at least was not renovated in a while. The shower is TINY!! Each time I needed to turn, I was hitting the knob of the shower with my back and I am not large woman. The door of the shower open directly to the toilet . The bathroom door never fully closed so one couldn’t have privacy. When we told them about our problem, they listen but did not move us to different room. So, it is hardly 5 star hotel . We stayed previously at Palladium hotel and we loved it. We should stay there again

If you care even slightly about your time, your wallet, or your mental health, avoid Hotel Casa Lucia like the plague. I flew halfway across the world — over 8,500 kilometers — for a trip I’d been planning for years. Casa Lucia managed to ruin it almost immediately. • Useless concierge: I asked for a basic dinner booking — they completely dropped the ball. My group lost a reservation that’s typically impossible to get without weeks of notice. Zero accountability, zero effort. • Tour screw-up: I requested help booking a day trip to Colonia del Sacramento. After a full day and a half of dodged messages and fake updates, they finally came clean: they never booked it. It was too late. One of the core reasons for my visit — gone. • Clueless about the city: Their so-called concierge had no idea what he was doing. I watched him Google restaurants like a tourist and send us to unsafe areas at night. I reached out to the Four Seasons concierge in frustration — they sorted me out in minutes. • Disgusting rooms: Mine reeked of mildew. The carpet was grimy, the furniture stained, and the bathroom looked like it hadn’t seen a cleaning crew in weeks. “Luxury”? Not even close. This place is a three-star motel trying to pass as something it’s not. Casa Lucia isn’t just incompetent — it’s a fraud. They think changing management will erase all this? It won’t. If anything, it’s a pathetic attempt to dodge accountability and deceive future guests. Melia should be ashamed to have its name anywhere near this disaster. Do yourself a favor and stay literally anywhere else. Buenos Aires has no shortage of amazing hotels. Casa Lucia doesn’t deserve to be in business, let alone on your itinerary.

I would say the staff is very poorly trained and rude, with the exception of Kevin, the reservation manager. He is exempt from the criticism I give. The hotel is old and tired. Our first stay gave us a superior room which was terrible. The carpet was dirty and the rest not much better. Our return we had a Jr. Suite. It was on a higher floor, but not much different except for the size. The shower is impossible. I could barely turn around. If I had dropped something, I couldn't have retrieved it. The food in the restaurant is appalling. The bacon is greasy and raw. There is no one to attend to cooking anything. The fruit was not edible, except for that that wasn't peeled. There are pastries mainly and sweets. The bread was tired and heavy. It was impossible to get service, let alone coffee or tea. There was only one woman that would acknowledge us. The spa isn't efficient. We both felt the masseuses weren't trained properly. Mine used her fingers and when I took a shower, noticed bruises along my arms and legs from her fingers. My husband felt the same. It wasn't comfortable either and very expensive, which shocked me. I was very ill, and Kevin did extend a late check out until 3:00. That was when we paid for the Jr. Suite. We had to wait until 6:30 in the lobby. It was awkward. It is also on a one-way street. We had dinner reservations and hired an Uber. There were two HUGE tour buses blocking the road. They shouldn't have been there as there isn't room. We waited for over 1/2 hour and finally got out and hired a cab.

We stayed here for 5 nights and received an upgrade to a Junior Suite which was lovely. The room was large and very well appointed. The hotel is located in a very quiet street in an upmarket area. Lots of cafes and restaurants within an easy walk. We had breakfast at the hotel every day - an excellent buffet + a small menu cooked to order. Staff mostly very friendly. We had dinner here as well - steak, of course - very nice. A small matter - because we were checking out early the next morning - around 7am - the day before we asked if it would be possible to have a simple packup breakfast - "no". As we were waiting for our transfer to the airport, the breakfast buffet was almost set up yet we were chastised for taking a few items to eat while we waited.

Located on a side street away from downtown but walking distance to a variety of shops and restaurants. Nice lobby but not much seating. Room was clean and comfortable. Downside—extremely poor service at bar/tapas restaurant and food was so-so. Not very hospitable to non-Spanish speaking guests. But did provide umbrellas for getting out on a rainy day.