The Cove Eleuthera

We went to the Cove’s restaurant for lunch and it was a terrible experience. The service was so slow and the food mediocre. We had to ask for napkins. The waitress left us for long periods of time without checking in. Our plates were not cleared. And to top it all they did not return our credit card. We had to wait over half an hour for them to locate it. Don’t go for a meal!

The resort looks serene. We did not stay on site, but rather reserved dinner for my daughters birthday. In short, as exclusive as this place is $1200 for a Buffett with food so tasteless and without creativity is obscene. I understand that food resource is scarce on the island but for the price I felt scammed. I am well traveled, have owned a restaurant and enjoy cooking. I am fine to pay top dollar for finely prepared food. It would have tasted better with ketchup. We were not the only ones who did not finish food due to lack of flavor or pizzazz. Wonderful staff. I enjoyed my Pink Sands margarita. For the money had I enjoyed my meal I would not be writing this.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Best Honeymoon Ever – Thanks to The Cove Team My wife and I spent our honeymoon at The Cove in Eleuthera, and it was absolutely perfect. The views and beaches are stunning, but it’s the staff who truly make this place unforgettable. Tory, TJ, Marlon, Sheeka, Alisha, Cream, Kendal, Lavelle, and so many others made us feel like family from the moment we arrived. We loved the art class with Lauren, snorkeling with Captain Spicy T and Deckhand Chad, paddle boarding around the cove, napping on the floating hammocks, and the Halloween event at the bar overlooking the sunset. The food—especially dinner and sushi—was incredible. The Cove is beautiful, but the kind and genuine people are what make it magical. They made our honeymoon an experience we’ll never forget.

Paradise! Quiet, romantic, secluded! Double coves and beaches w practically no one on them. Perfect snorkeling. Delicious food. Beautiful and recently remodeled rooms. Large & luxiurious room. Lovely team, Staff & mgmt bit still working out service links after remodel. If this sounds good book right away. If you want to party this is not the place for you….

We had a very good stay overall. The location was beautiful, the property itself was lovely, and all of the workers we interacted with were friendly and welcoming. Everything seemed clean and well kept for the most part. Unfortunately, we did have one issue that left us disappointed. On the last night of our stay, we noticed a dead cockroach in our room (photo attached). We let an employee know, but no one ever came to take care of it. We mentioned it again at checkout the next morning and received an apology. After returning home, we reached out to management about the situation. It has now been a month, and instead of addressing our concern, our emails just keep getting forwarded to different people without resolution. No partial refund or meaningful response has been offered. It’s unfortunate because we really enjoyed the property and the staff during our stay, but the lack of follow-up from management after the fact has left a sour impression.